Earlier this month I was quite confused. Although we are in the prime of summer--hot and humid Illinois weather--I hadn't gotten a single mosquito bite. Unfortunately I had that thought a little too soon. Last weekend when I awoke on Saturday morning I was covered in tiny red welts, evidence that my screen windows just aren't doing their job and that the little vampires had attacked me in the night. So what chemicals can help to keep away these pesky insects?
DEET, or meta-N,N-diethyl toluamide, is one of the most common mosquito repellents that I have seen used in the United States. While I haven't read any complete studies describing exactly how DEET works, it is believed that this molecule somehow binds to female mosquito sensory receptors (on a sidenote, generally it is only the female mosquitos that practice hematophagy, as they require extra protein in order to reproduce) and prevents them from recognizing some of the chemicals excreted by the human body, especially lactic acid and carbon dioxide. Inhibition of these receptors leaves the mosquito circling in confusion and allows us to enjoy itch-free summer evenings by the lake. DEET does have some unpleasant side effects; it can damage many synthetic fibers (though leaves cotton and many natural fibers untouched) and has long been known to have negative-side effects in aquatic life. Additionally, studies published in the Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health and Experimental Neurology by Mohamed Abou-Donia and coworkers have shown that prolonged use of DEET in rats can cause neurodegeneration, particularly in the cerebral cortex, the cerebellum, and the hippocampus [1], [2].
In Europe Icaridin / Picaridin is a common insect repellent, and some studies have shown that its activity is similar to that of DEET, but without any of the toxic side effects. Of course we all have heard of "natural" alternatives to these compounds, including citronella, beautyberry, geranium, lemon and eucalyptus oils, but did you know that catnip* (nepetalactone) has also been promoted as a "chemical free" means of eliminating mosquito bites [3], [4]? Interesting how the word chemical is generally considered taboo when promoting a new product; nepetalactone sure looks like an organic chemical to me!
If you are interested, the University of Florida has complied a list of several commonly available insect repellents with their effectiveness here.
If you are interested, the University of Florida has complied a list of several commonly available insect repellents with their effectiveness here.
*At the risk of sounding like carbon based curiosities, I just had to include some kind of reference to cats in this post. Last week I adopted a wonderful tabby! Isn't he cute?